The New Today
Local News

Stephen Croney convicted in second murder trial

Stephen Croney- has been found guilty of Cainissac Edwards murder

In a groundbreaking move, the Digital Forensics Unit of the Royal Grenada Police Force (RGPF) has played a crucial role in securing a conviction in the just-concluded Stephen Croney murder trial.

39-year-old Stephen Croney was on Tuesday found guilty of Non-Capital Murder in connection with the May 20, 2018 shooting death of 36-year-old Cainisaac Edwards in a unanimous verdict handed down by a jury of his peers.

The decision brings an end to a prolonged and complex legal battle that relied heavily on circumstantial evidence, which was tried before Madam Justice Paula Gilford at the St. George’s No.1 High Court.

This was Croney’s second trial, the first ended in a mistrial in October 2022 when the jury could not reach a unanimous decision and was divided 7-5.

According to Senior Crown Counsel in the Office of the Director of Public Prosecution (DPP) Howard Pinnock, the use of digital forensics by RGPF, which was not available during the first trial provided a crucial breakthrough in the case, enabling the Prosecution to construct a definitive timeline of Croney’s actions on the night of the murder.

“This time around I believe that we had a really solid set of jurors and we just pitched the case a little differently…and with the assistance now of this aspect of the apple (iphone) health data app, which tracked the movement of the (now) convicted man in terms of the number of steps covered and in terms of the distances covered, I believe in this case that was crucial,” Pinnock told THE NEW TODAY.

He noted, “the law in Grenada says that in cases of murder, the jury must be unanimous, that is all 12 of them must agree whether it be for an acquittal or for a conviction.”

Pinnock commended jurors for being “serious and focused, which is what we want in a court of law.”

The seven-week trial saw significant developments as the court scrutinised the details surrounding the 2018 murder of the deceased, a reputed drug lord in the Telescope area of St Andrew South-east.

The evidence presented in court was that Edwards was fatally shot by an assailant, disguised in a white overall and black bike helmet that was linked to the convicted man.

The shooting incident occurred near a popular bar in Telescope.

The shooter fired three shots, hitting Edwards in the chest, before fleeing the scene through some bushes from where he had lie in waiting to strike.

Edwards, known in the Telescope community as ‘Bally J’, was rushed to the Princess Alice Hospital in Mirabeau, St. Andrew, where he was pronounced dead.

The prosecution argued that Croney, who was represented in court by Attorney Andre Thomas, committed the murder in retaliation for a violent altercation the previous day, where he was attacked and injured by two masked men.

Croney contended that Edwards, who had accused him of having an affair with his female companion, had orchestrated the attack.

During both trials, Thomas highlighted Edwards’ questionable reputation and suggested that others may have had motives to kill him, citing inconsistencies in the Prosecution’s case.

The attorney declined to comment on the verdict when approached by reporters after the trial.

Devon Date, the nephew of the deceased, expressed mixed emotions about the verdict, noting that Croney had been like family to him and suggested that society had failed both men.

Date remembers his uncle as a “community figure” and described his killing as a big loss to the Telescope community.

“He was a very popular person in the community, the person that helped the youth in the community, help parents send their children to school. I mean you could go to Cain for money for break (and) lunch, that’s the kind of person he was. So, for the young people in the community it was a big loss to them because at that point in his life he was providing guidance to a lot of the people in the community,” he recalled.

Croney, who faces a maximum penalty of life in prison, had already spent about four (4) years on remand before being granted bail after his first trial.

He has been remanded to Richmond Hill Prison upon his conviction pending his sentencing, scheduled for July 30.

If you are satisfied with the information provided by The New Today to our many readers, followers and supporters around the world, then you can show your appreciation by making a financial contribution to the effort of our team of dedicated workers.

Giving back is a way of saying thank you for our efforts. 

Support The New Today