The New Today
Local News

Sexual Offenses continue to dominate the Assizes List

The three suspects - Ron Mitchell (l), Atiba Stanislaus (c) and Trevon Robertson (r) - charged with causing the death of U.S couple Ralph Hendry and Kathy Brandell in the Catamaran murder

The September Assizes opened on Tuesday with 85 criminal matters set for adjudication, 24 of which are new, while 61 have been carried over from the April session.

Although there has been a reduction from the 115 cases heard during the same period last year, sexual offenses continue to be a prevalent issue accounting for 34 cases.

Senior Crown Counsel in the Office of the Director of Public Prosecution Howard Pinnock described this as “of grave concern” as child victims continue to represent a large portion of sexual offense cases in Grenada, noting that 21 of the 34 sexual matters involves children under the age of 16.”

The docket comprises 20 homicides including Capital murder, Non-capital murder, Manslaughter, and death by dangerous driving, along with 13 non-fatal offences against a person, dangerous harm, maiming and grievous harm.

Representing the Grenada Bar Association (GBA), longstanding Criminal Defense attorney Anslem Clouden voiced concern about a significant gender imbalance in the jury selection pool for the September Assizes, questioning the fairness of the current process.

Of the 170 jurors summoned, only 19 are men, a disparity Clouden believes underscores the need for reform.

The jury selection in Grenada is managed by the Supreme Court Registrar and based on the electoral database, with individuals automatically becoming eligible for jury duty upon registering to vote.

However, Clouden is calling for a comprehensive review of this system to ensure a more balanced representation on jurors.

“I am calling for a rampant reform of the jury selection process,” Clouden said, emphasising the importance of fairness in the composition of juries.

He also addressed the burning issue surrounding the amended firearms legislation, which now limits Magistrates’ discretion to grant bail in firearm-related offenses, leaving such decisions solely in the hands of the High Court.

Clouden supported a proposal by attorney Jerry Edwin for regulations to expedite bail hearings at the High Court level.

“We are asking for a procedure whereby when you appear before the magistrate…if it is a bailable offence, simultaneously that application is made to the high court to be heard on that day because time is of the essence and the constitution guarantees the liberty of the subject.”

Related:  Bar Association comments on Hood/Pinnock issue

Another key issue raised by Clouden was the lack of legal provisions for addressing the mental health of offenders.

The veteran attorney noted that judges currently do not have the authority to direct mentally ill offenders to psychiatric institutions, resulting in their placement in prison, which he described as “inappropriate” for their treatment.

Clouden expressed the view that offenders with mental health challenges “are not conscious sometimes of the offences they create because of their mental illness and therefore sending them to the prison where they are under punitive supervision does not assist in a regime of treatment for such persons.”

Senior High Court Judge Madam Justice Paula Gilford who presided over the opening ceremony via Zoom, highlighted the absence of legal aid services for indigent defendants, urging the government to recruit attorneys willing to represent these individuals for a small fee.

She emphasised that many accused persons lack the knowledge to defend themselves, putting them at a disadvantage.

Several high-profile cases are set to be heard during the September Assizes with one involving three St. Andrew residents – Ron Mitchell, a 30-year-old sailor; Atiba Stanislaus, a 25-year-old farmer; and Trevon Robertson, a 23-year-old unemployed individual – linked to the Catamaran killing of two American yachties in February.

Another major case is the long-standing Oscar Bartholomew matter, which dates back almost 13 years.

It involves four suspended police officers, Edward Gibson, Shaun Ganness, Rody Felix, and Wendell Sylvester, who have been out on EC$100,000 bail since November 2017 and are set to stand trial for manslaughter.

Drug trafficking cases will also be prominent in this session, including those involving Dameion Francis and French national Serkan Yildirim.

Both men are facing charges related to a major EC$41.6 million cocaine bust that occurred on the sister isle of Carriacou in 2019.

This final session of the 2024 Assizes, the longest of the three annual sittings, includes several other noteworthy cases, such as the sentencing of Keiron Chitan for the 2020 shooting death of 16-year-old Lenisha Stanford and Stephen Croney for the 2018 murder of Cainisaac Edwards.

If you are satisfied with the information provided by The New Today to our many readers, followers and supporters around the world, then you can show your appreciation by making a financial contribution to the effort of our team of dedicated workers.

Giving back is a way of saying thank you for our efforts. 

Support The New Today