High Court judge Justice Agnes Actie has ruled against a Prison Officer who challenged the decision of the Commissioner of Prisons to prevent him from leaving the island without getting the permission of the Public Service Commission (PSC).
Keylon La Touche retained the services of Attorney-at-law Ruggles Ferguson, KC to challenge the decision taken to prevent him from boarding a flight at the Maurice Bishop International Airport (MBIA) to New York on vacation.
The court was told that Immigration Officers on directives from the Commissioner of Prisons did not allow the Prison Officer to board the flight on the grounds that he did not have written permission to leave the State.
The case for the State was put forward successfully by female attorney-at-law Camille Gooding-DeSouza who is attached to the Office of the Attorney-General.
In looking at the case, Justice Actie said that the real issue arising before the court is whether the policy requiring prison officers to obtain permission from the Commissioner or Superintendent of Prisons before leaving Grenada is ultra vires, unconstitutional under section 12 of the Constitution, and unlawful.”
The high court judge ruled that” “…The court is satisfied that Mr. LaTouche has not established any infringement of his constitutional right. The court finds that the requirement for him to obtain permission before travelling abroad falls within the lawful regulatory framework governing public officers, particularly prison officers, given the essential services they provide to the State and the possibility that they may be recalled from leave in the event of a prison crisis or other exigency.
“The court is therefore satisfied that the restriction is reasonably justifiable and falls within the constitutionally permitted limitations under section 12(3)(f) of the Constitution,” she said.
As a public service, THE NEW TODAY reproduces in full the Justice Agnes Actie ruling on the case involving the Prison Officer:-

