The New Today

Local News

Clouden calls for diplomatic intervention in war of words between Prime Ministers Mitchell and Gonsalves

Attorney Clouden – there should be diplomatic intervention

Outspoken attorney-at-law, Anselm Clouden who once promoted the idea of Carriacou & Petite Martinique breaking away from mainland Grenada has weighed in on the side of Prime Minister Dr. Ralph Gonsalves of St. Vincent & The Grenadines in the stand-off with his Grenadian counterpart, Dr. Keith Mitchell.

The two leaders have been involved in a spat over an offer from Dr. Gonsalves for residents of Carriacou & Petite Martinique to accept food supplies and cooking gas from his island which is Grenada’s nearest neighbour within the Caribbean Community (CARICOM) region.

An angry Dr. Mitchell accused Dr. Gonsalves of encouraging people to break the laws of Grenada in light of the decision taken by St. George’s to close all borders due to the coronavirus pandemic sweeping across the world.

In a statement made to THE NEW TODAY newspaper, Clouden called on Prime Minister Mitchell to allow commonsense to prevail and to accept the offer made by Dr. Gonsalves and to use diplomatic channels to resolve the issue.

According to Clouden, the two islands are both OECS and CARICOM and the important question to ask in this impasse is what has happened to the integration movement?

He called for Dr. Mitchell to enter into “amicable negotiations” with PM Ralph Gonsalves of St. Vincent & The Grenadines “to take delivery of the much needed assistance” that was offered to residents of Carriacou & Petite Martinique.

Clouden said: “As a Carriacouian, I want to express my profound gratitude to Prime Minister Dr. Ralph Gonsalves of St Vincent for his humanitarian consideration of the people of Carriacou and Petite Martinique in making that generous offer of providing much needed food and natural gas.

“The region is undergoing the most severe crisis in modern history at this time and we desperately need solidarity not rivalry. Grenada is not self-sufficient in food production and this government does not have an agricultural policy and even in this crucial time we cannot feed ourselves as no food security policy is in place.

“Dr Mitchell should accept the generous offer from his counterpart Prime Minister and summon his ambassador to work out the modalities of delivery of the food and gas. We must once again be mindful of the fact that after hurricane Ivan it was St Vincent and Prime Minister Ralph that provided Grenada with much needed food and gas.

“We the people of the Grenadines live as a big family, we have relatives in other islands. Union Island is almost part of Carriacou and we swim from Petite Martinique to PSV. It is a fact that we have traditionally been great neighbours with PSV. We must work together to manage our coastal resources through limited joint co-operation.

“We have not yet delimited our maritime boundaries, we have to introduce joint exploration of our fisheries resources. We share a common culture.

Dr. Gonsalves appears to be baffled by the outburst of his Grenadian counterpart, stating that he did not sought to encourage anyone to break the laws of Grenada.

A Vincentian online network carried the following article on the Keith Mitchell/Ralph Gonsalves spat: “First of all I have absolutely no interest in a village dog fight with Keith Mitchell. That’s what that is. The truth is, he initiated this village dog fight, but I don’t think he initiated it out of any malice, I think he was badly advised because for about ten days now if you come here from any country you’d be required to go under quarantine for 14 days,” Prime Minister Dr. Ralph Gonsalves told Asbert News Network, exclusively last Sunday, as he weighed in on what some are calling the continuing legacy of disagreements between the two OECS Leaders.

This most recent parry of cross border Prime Ministerial discordant exchanges were facilitated through the media as each country’s leader expressed his thoughts as to the sundry impacts of each country’s COVID-19 response on the other.

On April 6, the Grenadian Prime Minister told his island state’s media of his fears concerning the effect of SVG’s continuing open border policy on his administration’s COVID-19 strategy. The Maurice Bishop International Airport (GND) and the Lauriston Airport (CRU) were closed for all passenger traffic from March 23.

An additional measure imposed by the Grenadian authorities was to ban visitors from entering their country whose travel history proved they were in any of 36 countries, including: China Italy, Spain, the U.S and U.K, within 14 days of the arrival to Grenada.

In St. Vincent and the Grenadines on March 14 Dr. Gonsalves proposed reduced air travel tariffs and implored Vincentian hoteliers to offer discounts so as to drive up business in the local travel and accommodations sector.

“Effective March 19, all persons arriving from China, European Union (including Italy, the Overseas Departments of France), Iran, South Korea, USA (including USVI and PR), Canada and the UK will be subjected to mandatory 14 days quarantine.

Related:  Dwight Horsford spotted in G’da

“Effective March 28, all arriving passengers who meet the quarantine requirement will be required to sign an Undertaking to Quarantine form issued by the Ministry of National Security, Air and Seaport Development. All persons with a travel history including countries not listed will only be allowed into SVG once no symptoms of COVID-19 are exhibited. [And] quarantine on non-residents will be at a cost of the traveler,” a dispatch from the Barbados based US Embassy chronicled as it provided an update of the Eastern Caribbean’s COVID-19 Status as of April 9.

The Vincentian Prime Minister, now nearing the end of his fourth 5 years term, qualified Prime Minister Mitchell’s April 6 jab as a reaction to “old propaganda” which served to misdirect him on the status of SVG’s border control policy at that time.

“He probably listened to the old propaganda that Ralph have the borders open. In any case Union Island was closed to everything except legitimate trade. But if you came ashore you had to be quarantined for 14 days. So that’s the first big mistake that Keith made.

“The second one is that clearly he did not hear what I said; somebody must have told him because I said that they are our brothers and sisters in Carriacou and Petite Martinique and if they need food or gas or medicine we will help. But it has to be done in a structured manner,” Gonsalves told ANN on Sunday.

One day following Gonsalves’ offer to help, the Grenadian Prime Minister’s return volley was a curt reminder, “it is alarming that our citizens will be called upon to break the law by the leader of another country. It is grossly irresponsible and has the potential for not only legal consequences but also pose a significant threat to public health and public safety.

“My fellow Grenadians, particularly our brothers and sisters in Carriacou and Petite Martinique, do not be misguided into flouting the law of the land; do not knowingly endanger your health and that of your family. I encourage you to think and act wisely.

“There is no shortage of food and we are continuously revising our operations to ensure that we optimise the distribution of goods and restocking of grocery stores.”

Via ANN on Sunday, Dr. Gonsalves rhetorically lobbed back, “how can you move from I saying let’s do it in a structured manner to you going now to say that I encouraging them to come? I never encouraged them to come! Not in the way Keith Mitchell saying it. I said we will help but we will help in a structured manner.

“I understand that there are problems, when you lock down, with food and medicine and so on. Look, Petite Martinique people have been coming over to St. Vincent all the time to buy food and to buy medicines and same thing with Carriacou.

“And since the lock down in Grenada they have been coming because if they want food, folks would supply the food stuff for them.”

We asked Prime Minister Gonsalves to explain his definition of “help in a structured manner.”

He said, “a structured manner could be where individuals in Carriacou and Petite Martinique organise on the telephone or the internet with somebody that they’ve been dealing with all the time, tell them ‘we’re coming in to buy and so can you bring them in boxes on the pier?’ And let them be delivered there so that there’s very little contact with one another and they would make the payments.

“Or, the [Grenadian] governmental authority can do it in relation with another governmental authority in St. Vincent. The Director of Grenadine Affairs, he’s down in Union Island and if they want more stuff than they have at the time in Union Island we could always send down stuff.

“So it could be done as a normal private trade because remember … the people who [come to] buy the stuff they don’t come ashore. In much the same way we send provisions to Trinidad and the boat men don’t go ashore.

“Doing the thing in a structured way is not anything that is novel. It happens all the time and if they want to include the governmental authority we have the Director of Grenadine Affairs, Edwin Snagg, and he himself has a business down there….

“All of us have an interest in the people in Carriacou and Petite Martinique to get food, medicine, gas. I don’t want to break Keith Mitchell regulations that he has. I’m not that kind of person. Clearly, neither the quarantine nor the lockdown is as effective as they should be because fellas leaving by boat and coming and buying things’’.

If you are satisfied with the information provided by The New Today to our many readers, followers and supporters around the world, then you can show your appreciation by making a financial contribution to the effort of our team of dedicated workers.

Giving back is a way of saying thank you for our efforts

Support The New Today