The New Today

Commentary

Mt. Dor Road: Mr. Gajadhar ‘doth protest too much’

In a recent GBN interview, Rayneau Construction’s Managing Director, Mr. Rayneau Gajadhar, explained how his company constructed a temporary bypass through its industrial compound, which, by his own admission, lasted only about a week before the company returned to repairing the collapsed sections of the original Mt. Dor Road.

In the interview with GBN, he also reported that engineering assessments had found no connection between the road failures and Rayneau’s operations.  Did GBN have access to this report?

Two matters deserve attention here.

First, Mt. Dor Road is a public road, not part of Rayneau’s industrial estate. Grenada has laws governing public roads, public works and government procurement.

Section 9 of the Roads Act vests authority in the Minister to execute schemes approved by the Road Authority. What, then, is the legal basis for Rayneau’s involvement?

Mr. Gajadhar referred to discussions with the Ministry of Infrastructure. Elsewhere, he has described his involvement as helping the Parliamentary Representative for St. John, Ms. Kerryne James. Incidentally, she is also the Minister for Climate Resilience and the Environment.

But reconstructing a public road is not a personal favour to a member of the administration, it is a public undertaking that demands public accountability.

Was Rayneau awarded a contract? Is the company being paid or reimbursed? Is it undertaking the work voluntarily? Was an emergency arrangement invoked, and under whose authority?

Regardless of who pays, who approved the engineering design, who is supervising the repairs, and who will certify that the reconstructed road is safe?  The Ministry of Infrastructure owes the public an explanation.

The second matter is perhaps even more troubling.

Mr. Gajadhar ‘Doth Protest Too Much’
Mr. Gajadhar has sought to distance his company’s operations from the Mt Dor road failures. Yet what is indisputable is that the road has collapsed at several locations along the stretch adjoining Rayneau’s industrial development.

Residents who have lived in the area for more than 30 years say they have never witnessed destruction of this magnitude – so many failures, in such close succession, and with such severity.

Cracks appeared during the dry season, note it was not the rainy season, as he has said in previous reports. Another section failed in June, followed by the major collapses in July.

And now, remarkably, Mr. Gajadhar is warning of another possible collapse. “There is a potential area which may slide,” he said. “We’re going to work on it.”

And where is this threatened section? Along the stretch adjoining Rayneau’s operations, where substantial quantities of stone have been removed, a photograph taken at that location shows stone being loaded onto a truck for transportation elsewhere.

None of this, by itself, establishes that Rayneau’s operations caused the earlier failures. But surely the concentration of these failures along the adjoining hillside demands independent investigation.

What has led Mr. Gajadhar to anticipate another collapse? Have engineers identified signs of instability? And if engineering assessments have already cleared Rayneau of responsibility, who conducted them, what did they examine, and where are their reports?

More importantly, why are the Physical Planning and Development Authority (PDA) and the Ministry of Infrastructure allowing stone removal to continue along this vulnerable stretch without publicly demonstrating that the road is safe?

For more than 30 years, residents lived alongside this road without witnessing destruction on this scale. As one resident says, “the government has stood by and looked at Rayneau remove all the stones from land, turning it into porridge, this is unconscionable”.

Now that several sections have collapsed, another is said to be at risk, and stone removal continues.

Why is stone removal continuing alongside a road where Rayneau’s own Managing Director now warns that another collapse may take place?

Where is the PDA? Where is the Ministry of Infrastructure? Where is the Government?

The above was submitted by Grenada Land Actors