The New Today

Commentary

Before the Wrecking ball falls: Will Grenada upgrade or erase a priority Heritage site?

At the recent National Tourism Symposium, Minister for Tourism, Creative Economy and Culture, Hon. Adrian Thomas, identified “the coordinated upgrading of priority tourism sites” as one of the Government’s objectives.

He also made the important point that Grenada must increase visitor spending by making it easier for visitors to experience, pay for, and recommend authentic local products. That is the correct national direction.

Yet there is an urgent contradiction that demands Government attention. In the heart of St.  George’s, the Drill Yard – a site connected to Grenada’s court, prison, military, labour, resistance, civic and cultural history – is facing demolition.

Grenada cannot credibly speak of upgrading priority tourism sites while allowing a significant component of the Fort

George and St. George’s historic landscape to disappear without a full heritage review, salvage plan, archaeological assessment, and Government decision on its future.

The Drill Yard is not merely a fire-damaged building or an old car parked on Young Street. From 1740, it formed part of the Palais de Justice complex, which housed Grenada’s early court and prison.

It was connected to Fort George through the former Fort Street corridor and later stairs. Its surviving ruins are associated with prison cells, the incarceration of enslaved and free persons, the punishment of apprentices, the aftermath of Fedon’s Rebellion, military drill, public administration, the first calypso tent, a corn mill, a clinic, and other chapters of Grenada’s story.

This is difficult history. It includes justice and injustice, punishment and resistance, colonialism and freedom, military authority and cultural expression. That is precisely why it matters.

At the 1 July meeting convened by the National Insurance Scheme, the NIS made clear that its principal concern is public safety.

The NIS explained that it had relied on engineering advice, that two firms recommended demolition, and that it does not wish to risk injury from falling bricks or other deteriorating material.

That concern is legitimate. No responsible heritage organisation can ask that a dangerous site be left unsecured.

But the national choice is not between demolition and doing nothing.

The proper choice is between: first, securing the site while a rapid, professional review is completed; or second, demolishing a nationally significant place before Grenada has fully assessed what can safely remain, what must be removed, what must be documented, and what should be salvaged for public benefit.

The NIS has allowed stakeholders one week to survey the site and has indicated that it will pay for storage of materials removed during demolition. This is a constructive opening.

However, storing demolished bricks after the fact is not the same as preserving history.

Once walls are pulled down, foundations disturbed, and archaeological layers removed, the relationship between materials, place, and meaning may be lost forever.

The Grenada National Museum has correctly called for documentation, architectural recording, salvage, archaeological monitoring, and public interpretation before irreversible action.

The Grenada National Trust and the Willie Redhead Foundation support that approach. Public safety must be secured, but Grenada must not confuse emergency stabilisation with wholesale erasure.

The law points to a balanced approach. The Grenada National Trust Act, 1967, established the Trust to identify and document historic buildings and monuments, preserve heritage material, educate the public, pursue preservation policy, advise Government, acquire property for the benefit of Grenadians, and raise funds through grants and donations.

The Physical Planning and Development Control Act, 2016, goes further. It requires Grenada to protect cultural heritage in the built environment while also securing health and safety.

It recognises demolition as a planning matter. It establishes the Natural and Cultural Heritage Advisory Committee to advise the Planning and Development Authority on heritage protection.

It also gives the Authority the power to issue an interim preservation order for an unlisted building, monument, or site, allowing up to 90 days for urgent assessment and a decision on listing. That mechanism exists for exactly this kind of moment.

The question is not whether the Drill Yard needs intervention. It plainly does. The question is whether Grenada will intervene in a way that destroys the evidence of its history, or in a way that safeguards, interprets, and reuses that history for present and future generations.

The Government should therefore act immediately. First, the Planning and Development Authority should consider an interim preservation order to create a lawful period for review.

Second, Government should convene an emergency technical team comprising the PDA, NIS, Grenada National Museum, Grenada National Trust, Willie Redhead Foundation, Ministry of Tourism, Creative Economy and Culture, Ministry of Finance, and qualified conservation and structural engineers.

Third, the site should undergo a rapid but comprehensive review: an independent structural and safety assessment; heritage and archaeological documentation; identification of features that can be stabilised; a demolition-salvage protocol for any material that cannot safely remain; and a plan for public interpretation.

Fourth, Cabinet should authorise negotiations with the NIS to repurchase or otherwise transfer the property back into public heritage stewardship. The NIS should not be expected to carry an indefinite heritage-management burden.

A negotiated Government acquisition would remove a safety and maintenance liability from the NIS while allowing the State, the Museum, and the GNT to pursue conservation, grant funding, and sustainable use. This is not an unrealistic proposition.

The GNT’s Heritage Economy Transformation Framework shows that Grenada does not need massive growth in visitor arrivals to generate more local benefit.

A modest five percent conversion of existing visitors into structured heritage experiences was estimated to produce approximately EC$7.1 million in illustrative annual heritage revenue in 2025, based on an average visitor spend of EC$250.

The point is not that the Drill Yard alone will generate that amount. The point is that Grenada’s heritage assets, when connected and properly interpreted, can create real visitor spending, employment, cultural enterprise, and reinvestment in preservation.

Fort George should be the flagship heritage anchor. The Drill Yard should be part of the surrounding heritage landscape: Fort George, Young Street, Church Street, the Grenada National Museum, Market Square, historic churches, York House, craft, food, storytelling, and community-based experiences.

A visitor route that begins at Fort George and moves through the historic town needs authentic places, not erased spaces.

The Drill Yard could become a carefully conserved Heritage Court and Interpretation Site: a place where Grenadians and visitors can learn about the history of justice, imprisonment, enslavement, resistance, emancipation, military life, and cultural transformation.

It could support school programmes, Museum-linked exhibits, guided tours, oral history, digital interpretation, heritage talks, and appropriately managed cultural events. Its purpose would not be to commercialise pain, but to tell Grenada’s story truthfully and respectfully.

There is also international support for this direction. Catherine Leonard, Secretary-General of the International National Trusts Organisation, has recognised the GNT as a technical and strategic partner and has encouraged Grenada to strengthen the Trust’s role in caring for properties, developing flagship sites such as Fort George, attracting investment, and building a wider national heritage offer.

Grenada has before it a practical test of national policy.

Will the Government’s commitment to coordinated upgrading of tourism sites include the places that make St. George’s historic, distinctive, and marketable? Will Cabinet protect the Drill Yard long enough to determine its real value?

Will the country establish a protocol so that no important heritage site is again placed on a demolition schedule before the Museum, GNT, Willie Redhead Foundation, the relevant heritage committee, and the public have been properly engaged?

The NIS is right to insist on safety. But Grenada must be equally be firm in insisting on stewardship.

Secure what is dangerous. Salvage what cannot be saved. Preserve what can remain. Reacquire what belongs in public heritage care. And put the Drill Yard to sustainable use as part of Grenada’s flagship heritage future.

Once the wrecking ball falls, no grant, apology, or future tourism plan can rebuild the original evidence of Grenada’s past.

Dr. Ezra B. Matthias is First Vice President of the Grenada National Trust